MR2 Roadster Owners Club

The Workshop => General => Topic started by: Zxrob on January 20, 2020, 22:02

Title: Hard tops
Post by: Zxrob on January 20, 2020, 22:02
I see a lot of folks have or are looking for/willing to purchase a hard top for their roadster

Erm why, personally I dont think the hard top looks that great on an MR2, bit like an after thought

Obviously, just my opinion

Your thoughts/opinions ;)

Rob

Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: SV-3 on January 20, 2020, 22:11
Quote from: Zxrob on January 20, 2020, 22:02I see a lot of folks have or are looking for/willing to purchase a hard top for their roadster

Erm why, personally I dont think the hard top looks that great on an MR2, bit like an after thought

Obviously, just my opinion

Your thoughts/opinions ;)

Rob


I guess it's all in the eye of the beholder and this beholder thinks it looks bloody marvellous 8)
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Zxrob on January 20, 2020, 22:20
Quote from: SV-3 on January 20, 2020, 22:11I guess it's all in the eye of the beholder

Yep, I'll agree with that ^^^^

Perhaps I should go to "spec savers" or perhaps not  :)  ;)

Rob
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 22:25
This now non beholder, views it as the best modification I have done. Selling the one I had.
A phaff taking it off and putting back on again. Single or double handed.
Took up space when it was off. Hung on the wall in bag.
Dead money.
Extra weight
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Bossworld on January 20, 2020, 22:36
Sold mine to fund subframe replacement. Annoyingly think I priced it too low given the colour and how good condition it was, and the buyer sold it for more a few months down the line (their prerogative I suppose).

Still, although the rear visibility is much better and IMO it changes handling for the better, I don't miss the rattles and the car lives in the garage over winter anyway.

Think they need a spoiler fitted to the car to give it a bit of a break appearance wise
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 20, 2020, 22:38
I like the hardtop a lót!
A very good design to boot, very easy to fit/take off. Space I have so no issue there.


(https://myalbum.com/photo/R23bM5a1h5CE/1k0.jpg)
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Bernie on January 20, 2020, 22:44
Each to their own for me the 2's hardtop does suit the car and makes it a car for all seasons I love the versatility and, shock horror, can be taken off inside 2 minutes it's not a permanent fixture

DB150102-9F01-470B-A6F9-EC53AFE57CDA.jpeg

Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 22:47
Quote from: Bossworld on January 20, 2020, 22:36Still, although the rear visibility is much better
Better than not there at all, how can that be?
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 20, 2020, 22:57
Quote from: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 22:47
Quote from: Bossworld on January 20, 2020, 22:36Still, although the rear visibility is much better
Better than not there at all, how can that be?

Barring the detail of bad weather. Even here. At the moment I am still not up to scratch, with a bad flu imported from China by Malaga gf, otherwise I would have the hardtop fitted last week till at least next weekend.

A small positive side effect is that with hard top fitted the soft top drains have naught to do.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 23:19
Quote from: Petrus on January 20, 2020, 22:57
Quote from: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 22:47
Quote from: Bossworld on January 20, 2020, 22:36Still, although the rear visibility is much better
Better than not there at all, how can that be?

Barring the detail of bad weather. Even here. At the moment I am still not up to scratch, with a bad flu imported from China by Malaga gf, otherwise I would have the hardtop fitted last week till at least next weekend.

A small positive side effect is that with hard top fitted the soft top drains have naught to do.
Damn cheap chinese imports. Don't need them. We have our own perfectly good full fat versions of flu doing the rounds.
Rattly chest infection - sore throat - blocked nose - runny nose - headache - shivers - coughing - sneezing - loss of taste - loss of hearing, tingly nose and whatever else I've forgotten to add. Still, as ever I just carried on.

Have heard countries are screening those traveling from China. Has Spain adopted this yet?
We should, but probably won't.
By the time they get past passport control officer, it will have ran its course anyway.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: househead on January 20, 2020, 23:25
Quote from: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 22:25This now non beholder, views it as the best modification I have done. Selling the one I had.
A phaff taking it off and putting back on again. Single or double handed.
Took up space when it was off. Hung on the wall in bag.
Dead money.
Extra weight

As Carolyn put it and I totally agree with her ... it's like a new car twice a year!

There has been the odd sunny winter day I've been tempted to take it off temporarily but I've resisted. It's gonna be great when I do whip it off for the first time in 2020 and get back to some open top motoring. For now though, I'm enjoying the different car feel, it's quieter, more rigid, warmer and with better rear visibility (though I do concede nothing beats top-down for that).

Looks-wise, I think the car looks great in all 3 configurations ... top-down, soft-top up and hard top. My missus agrees too, and she's totally impartial, unlike us!
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: jvanzyl on January 20, 2020, 23:37
Quote from: Zxrob on January 20, 2020, 22:02I see a lot of folks have or are looking for/willing to purchase a hard top for their roadster

Erm why, personally I dont think the hard top looks that great on an MR2, bit like an after thought

Obviously, just my opinion

Your thoughts/opinions ;)

Rob



Scotte?? is this your other account??
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 23:57
Quote from: househead on January 20, 2020, 23:25For now though, I'm enjoying the different car feel, it's quieter, more rigid, warmer and with better rear visibility (though I do concede nothing beats top-down for that).

Looks-wise, I think the car looks great in all 3 configurations ... top-down, soft-top up and hard top. My missus agrees too, and she's totally impartial, unlike us!
Warmer? does your heater not work?
As D has this coldy fluy thing that's going round, I summoned up all the compassion I could find and put the soft top up just for her. I know sacrifices. Heater was set to fan 2 briefly. Like an oven and that's with just a bit of flimsy canvas.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: 1979scotte on January 21, 2020, 06:08
Hardtop looks great but then it's not a convertible.

Heaters work great too if yours doesn't then you've got air in the system.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: tets on January 21, 2020, 06:21
ive deleted the soft top and used Rogue fixings so it is sort of permanent!! But it is a road going hillclimb car

Got to say I prefer the look of mine with it on
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: 105e on January 21, 2020, 08:33
Hardtop looks better to me, soft tops look best on old cars from the nineteen thirties, forties, fifties. Think any modernish aerodynamic looking car just looks wrong with a soft top..
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: househead on January 21, 2020, 09:16
Quote from: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 23:57
Quote from: househead on January 20, 2020, 23:25For now though, I'm enjoying the different car feel, it's quieter, more rigid, warmer and with better rear visibility (though I do concede nothing beats top-down for that).

Looks-wise, I think the car looks great in all 3 configurations ... top-down, soft-top up and hard top. My missus agrees too, and she's totally impartial, unlike us!
Warmer? does your heater not work?
As D has this coldy fluy thing that's going round, I summoned up all the compassion I could find and put the soft top up just for her. I know sacrifices. Heater was set to fan 2 briefly. Like an oven and that's with just a bit of flimsy canvas.

Heater works fine, as well as you describe! I guess what I meant it that it's warmer to get into and warmer before the car heats up.

@1979scotte you know I don't have any air in there as you very kindly helped me bleed it all out!
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 21, 2020, 09:23
All this hard top talk...
I agree with the three in one car. The driving experiences are different and all good.
I´ll try put it on this afternoon and see how the wing looks with it  8)
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Ozzy on January 21, 2020, 10:23
(https://i.ibb.co/QYtPV3D/johnsmr2spyder-20200119-0001.jpg)


I'm sort off half and half with hard tops. I think they only suit modified MR2s. Stock ones just look too round, without a spoiler or being lowered, etc.

I thought about getting one but not really worth spending the money on a cheap daily and hassle that comes with it. If one could be brought for a bargain, maybe.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Bossworld on January 21, 2020, 10:39
Quote from: Ardent on January 20, 2020, 22:47
Quote from: Bossworld on January 20, 2020, 22:36Still, although the rear visibility is much better
Better than not there at all, how can that be?

Time and a place for soft top down with my luscious (thinning) locks and if I don't want to look like Brian May by the time I get to work, it's roof up :)
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Zxrob on January 21, 2020, 11:11
Quote from: Ozzy on January 21, 2020, 10:23I think they only suit modified MR2s. Stock ones just look too round, without a spoiler or being lowered, etc.

Pretty much my thoughts, as I said, they look a bit of an after thought on a standard car

Each to their own though

Rob
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: james_ly on January 21, 2020, 11:18
I ran mine with a hardtop for a while... it's nice but in the end I couldn't see the point. Makes the wind noise less but other than that didn't really notice much difference. Personally I think the extra rigidity is mostly placebo..
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: SV-3 on January 21, 2020, 11:28
Quote from: james_ly on January 21, 2020, 11:18I ran mine with a hardtop for a while... it's nice but in the end I couldn't see the point. Makes the wind noise less but other than that didn't really notice much difference. Personally I think the extra rigidity is mostly placebo..
Just like Viagra then >:D
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 21, 2020, 11:29
Oh my; 10 cm of SNÓW on Torremolinos to Benalmadena beach!

Putting some extra effort in it  ;D

I like the less confined space and wáy better rear view. I also like the finish on the inside a lot.

More or less noise is irrelevant with my exhaust  O:-)

Rigidity? Nah. Not unless you seriously bolt it down.

One thing more: With the softop I do not lock the car. I´d rather they nick something without cutting the it. With hardtop I do, if I remember to.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: J88TEO on January 21, 2020, 11:32
On in Winter and off in Summer for me.
Keeps the wet, damp and cold weather out!
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Joesson on January 21, 2020, 11:47
I bought my 2 as a top down only fun car and only use it on fine days and it lives in the garage for 6 months at a time.
Having, of necessity, driven in the rain with the top up I found that it didn't appeal to me.
The problem I have is with the OE soft top on cooler days, it doesn't want to fold and so has to be idled or driven to get the heater to do it's job, ease the vinyl/ fabric  and allow it to drop.
On that basis, if I were to be an all season driver, a hard top could be a solution.
But, a hard top costs around £500 and my understanding is that a cloth/ fabric top is available for just North of £300 and that material allows dropping and raising the hood to be a very quick and easy process.
I am aware of one top down devotee that this seems to work for.

PS: Last evening on a Midlands Mway at around 23.00 hours and 0 degrees I passed a TT with it's top down!
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: J88TEO on January 21, 2020, 12:33
PS: Last evening on a Midlands Mway at around 23.00 hours and 0 degrees I passed a TT with it's top down!

Electric motor kaput!
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 21, 2020, 13:21
Quote from: J88TEO on January 21, 2020, 12:33PS: Last evening on a Midlands Mway at around 23.00 hours and 0 degrees I passed a TT with it's top down!

Electric motor kaput!

In general the sheer endless variety of little things that can stop an electric folding roof is mind boggling. However, there always is a manual fail safe to wind the roof up or down .... only to discover that some lever has unlevered and by manual winding damaged beyond repair. Although only one simple lever which can be easily disassembled, it is part of a subassembly which can only be bought as one part. The 10 Euro plastic now costing 600.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Joesson on January 21, 2020, 13:38
Quote from: J88TEO on January 21, 2020, 12:33PS: Last evening on a Midlands Mway at around 23.00 hours and 0 degrees I passed a TT with it's top down!

Electric motor kaput!

I'm not a Luddite (really I'm not) but that simply didn't occur to me.
Vor sprung dirch technique , or whatever the correct spelling is of the one time Audi Advert surely wouldn't allow that to go wrong would it !
PS Thinking about it now, it did look strange and I could have been seeing part of the frame extended, hence the lower than the limit speed of the TT.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 21, 2020, 16:26
Right, started car, let is warm the interior a bit while I rearranged the starage a bit for easier access to the hard top.

Folded top down and with help of my son put the lid on. What a joy of well thought through ease.
And agree with those who commented on spoilers; it does look even better with the wing I think.

Was not planning on taking De Kikker out before next week and then it is probably dry but now I most likely wíll!
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Johnny5 on January 22, 2020, 06:50
Lurv my hardtop.  Unlike many on these venerable pages, I didn't buy my 2 for the convertible experience.  I wasn't actually looking for a convertible at all.  I was just after a cheeky, chuckable little sports car, an objective I have achieved, and buying my hardtop has enabled me to do so whilst maintaining my preference for a FHC.

That said, with the ability to go lidless in the summer, I do take advantage of it and run the car in convertible form about 4 months of the year.  I only really feel the benefit on 25+ degree days, though.

Two other issues:

1. I sometimes have to park my car under a tree, and some of the birds round here do concrete poo.  Much easier to clean off a hardtop than a vinyl soft top.

2. I'm definitely a little more careful where I drive/stop/park the car when running it as a convertible.  Quick story.  About 18 years ago, I was driving my hatchback through a dodgy area west of London and needed some petrol, so pulled in to fuel station.  Got out of car, standing next to petrol pump, with wallet in one hand and car keys in other, in full view.  Just then, I noticed a group of hoodies ambling down the road slowly, past the forecourt.  They looked and saw me, holding wallet and keys, and they changed direction, veering off the pavement and on to the forecourt straight towards me.  They didn't rush me at first, they were waiting till they were close enough that I couldn't do anything before rushing me, pretending to act calm.  Suspecting that their sudden course correction wasn't just a coincidence, I took evasive action by getting in the car and pushing down the central locking button.  And they changed direction again back on to the pavement and went on their way.  It was no coincidence.  They were going to mug/carjack me.  I do a self defense course now, so I'm always thinking, "Better to avoid [dangerous people, places and situations] than to to run; better to run that to de-escalate; better to de-escalate than to fight; better to fight than to die".  I did the right thing on that day, but I'm aware that if I'd been driving a convertible with the hood down, they likely would've had me.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Call the midlife! on January 22, 2020, 07:13
Quote from: Johnny5 on January 22, 2020, 06:50Lurv my hardtop.  Unlike many on these venerable pages, I didn't buy my 2 for the convertible experience.  I wasn't actually looking for a convertible at all.  I was just after a cheeky, chuckable little sports car, an objective I have achieved, and buying my hardtop has enabled me to do so whilst maintaining my preference for a FHC.

That said, with the ability to go lidless in the summer, I do take advantage of it and run the car in convertible form about 4 months of the year.  I only really feel the benefit on 25+ degree days, though.

Two other issues:

1. I sometimes have to park my car under a tree, and some of the birds round here do concrete poo.  Much easier to clean off a hardtop than a vinyl soft top.

2. I'm definitely a little more careful where I drive/stop/park the car when running it as a convertible.  Quick story.  About 18 years ago, I was driving my hatchback through a dodgy area west of London and needed some petrol, so pulled in to fuel station.  Got out of car, standing next to petrol pump, with wallet in one hand and car keys in other, in full view.  Just then, I noticed a group of hoodies ambling down the road slowly, past the forecourt.  They looked and saw me, holding wallet and keys, and they changed direction, veering off the pavement and on to the forecourt straight towards me.  They didn't rush me at first, they were waiting till they were close enough that I couldn't do anything before rushing me, pretending to act calm.  Suspecting that their sudden course correction wasn't just a coincidence, I took evasive action by getting in the car and pushing down the central locking button.  And they changed direction again back on to the pavement and went on their way.  It was no coincidence.  They were going to mug/carjack me.  I do a self defense course now, so I'm always thinking, "Better to avoid [dangerous people, places and situations] than to to run; better to run that to de-escalate; better to de-escalate than to fight; better to fight than to die".  I did the right thing on that day, but I'm aware that if I'd been driving a convertible with the hood down, they likely would've had me.
The hooded youth are indeed a menace, I've seen various instances of them throwing things into open tops, rubbish off the street, traffic cones etc. I always get a bit nervy when sat in traffic next to the pavement in towns and cities, always try and have the kerbside window up to deter anyone from reaching in.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: tricky1138 on January 22, 2020, 09:28
I do / did like the hard top and only got rid of mine as it is now a weekend fun car rather than my daily.

Running the car through winter when its dark and cold on the morning commute and dark and cold on the evening commute, the opportunity to get the roof down was almost non-existent, so having the quieter, better visibility hard top was the option for me. Sunny weekends and the roof would be off though!

Now that I dont use it all the time, I dont see a need for the hard top, as I bought the car for the convertible fun it is - the rest of the car just makes it more fun!

I would have bought a FWD front engined convertible had I not stumbled across the MR2! :o  :o  :o 
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 22, 2020, 10:07
Quote from: Johnny5 on January 22, 2020, 06:501. I sometimes have to park my car under a tree, and some of the birds round here do concrete poo.  Much easier to clean off a hardtop than a vinyl soft top.
Have a photo of a bird droppting her vinyl top on mine....

Quote2. I'm definitely a little more careful where I drive/stop/park the car when running it as a convertible.  Quick story.  About 18 years ago, I was driving my hatchback through a dodgy area west of London and needed some petrol, so pulled in to fuel station.  Got out of car, standing next to petrol pump, with wallet in one hand and car keys in other, in full view.  Just then, I noticed a group of hoodies ambling down the road slowly, past the forecourt.  They looked and saw me, holding wallet and keys, and they changed direction, veering off the pavement and on to the forecourt straight towards me.  They didn't rush me at first, they were waiting till they were close enough that I couldn't do anything before rushing me, pretending to act calm.  Suspecting that their sudden course correction wasn't just a coincidence, I took evasive action by getting in the car and pushing down the central locking button.  And they changed direction again back on to the pavement and went on their way.  It was no coincidence.  They were going to mug/carjack me.  I do a self defense course now, so I'm always thinking, "Better to avoid [dangerous people, places and situations] than to to run; better to run that to de-escalate; better to de-escalate than to fight; better to fight than to die".  I did the right thing on that day, but I'm aware that if I'd been driving a convertible with the hood down, they likely would've had me.

Had one very much alike when underway in my previous ragtop to collect my Spyder funnily enough. They even had a pitbull. Being tall, well trained and having written books on dogtraining and training/behaviour in general, it was on the line between fun and scary to see how body language confused them and the dog wag its tail.
I am sure the previous rugged ragtop was a better perspective than the teeny weeny hairdressers spyder.

On the avoiding; I have an arab treaty of furusiyya and it is só relaistically different from westerm ´chivalry´; the handbook for the horseman how in detail to fight in specific situations with different arms, several times simply says; ride away. Lóve it but am not put together that way :-(
Congrats on your wisdom. Would have been and be to my benefit if I had it. Done too many REALLY stupid things that even at the time seemed a bad idea but hey... hormones. It always galls me that women can use their hormone cycle as valid excuse for erraic behavior whereas we can not yet men suffer that hormone imbalance ALL THE TIME!!

Right, back to the subject.
A detail; the profile of the roof line, the lowered bit in the middle, I find styling genious. It gives maximum headroom without rasing he topline too much.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: househead on January 22, 2020, 10:21
Quote from: Johnny5 on January 22, 2020, 06:501. I sometimes have to park my car under a tree, and some of the birds round here do concrete poo.  Much easier to clean off a hardtop than a vinyl soft top.

Soft-top poo removal ... wait for it to dry fully first, scrape off, brush the residue.

Hard-top / paint ... take off while wet if possible. Wet it first with a spray bottle if it's already dried.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: SV-3 on January 22, 2020, 11:49
Quote from: Petrus on January 22, 2020, 10:07Right, back to the subject.
A detail; the profile of the roof line, the lowered bit in the middle, I find styling genious. It gives maximum headroom without rasing he topline too much.

Spot on Petrus - I love the way "the lowered bit" starts in the front bumper, is repeated on the bonnet and the roof and finishes across the rear lid. Full marks to the guys at Toyota for making the effort. You know, sometimes we look but we don't see and sometimes words fail me... ;)  8)
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 22, 2020, 12:26
Quote from: SV-3 on January 22, 2020, 11:49
Quote from: Petrus on January 22, 2020, 10:07Right, back to the subject.
A detail; the profile of the roof line, the lowered bit in the middle, I find styling genious. It gives maximum headroom without rasing he topline too much.

Spot on Petrus - I love the way "the lowered bit" starts in the front bumper, is repeated on the bonnet and the roof and finishes across the rear lid. Full marks to the guys at Toyota for making the effort. You know, sometimes we look but we don't see and sometimes words fail me... ;)  8)

I am surprised how few paint/vinyl personalisations make use of this quite distinctive styling feature. In ´Gulf´ livery it is even ignored...

If I would not have had my personal theme for a long time earlier I would have not had a doubt. Even then though, I tried follow some of the design lines with the red ´flutes´.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Mackie on January 26, 2020, 21:59
Anybody need a hardtop
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Joesson on January 26, 2020, 22:05
That's ( something) like asking if anybody likes Marmite!
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Joesson on January 26, 2020, 22:08
Seriously, that is a valuable commodity that "some" Members have, and others yearn for, while true believers go topless.
If you have a hard top, and you are a true believer, put the top up for sale in the "For Sale" section.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Mackie on January 26, 2020, 22:26
Hi
Have a hard top for sale
Showroom condition
Offers.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Bernie on January 26, 2020, 22:31
Quote from: Mackie on January 26, 2020, 22:26Hi
Have a hard top for sale
Showroom condition
Offers.


Doesn't work like that here post up a sales thread with pics and state a price

Read the rules on selling too please

https://www.mr2roc.org/forum/index.php?topic=22555.0
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Ardent on January 26, 2020, 22:31
Quote from: Mackie on January 26, 2020, 21:59Anybody need a hardtop
Sounds like you are looking to give it away.
In which case I will help you out and take it off yours hands.
Then immediately put it up for sale myself.

Like @Joesson says. Put it up for sale in the private sales section.
And don't forget, the fitting kit is nigh on worth the same. As ridiculous as it seems.

Edit
Doh cross post
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 26, 2020, 23:04
Hard tops will by defininition become more common. They already have.
Hard tops get sold on when cars get scrapped = when the number of cars halves, the % of hard top doubles.
Title: Re: Hard tops
Post by: Petrus on January 27, 2020, 15:40
Sunny weather for a least a week so took the hard top off again. Pushed the car back into the sun, hour later hard top off and in storage, soft top up, pushed car under the roof again: 5 minutes tops.

Made for a nice change, a few days of hard top driving. Has rather a luxury feel to it. Am also inclined to travel at higher speeds; 20 - 30+ km/h ´cruising´. Good thing it´s off again ;-)