MR2 Roadster Owners Club

The Workshop => Audio / Security / Electrical => Topic started by: moca2cv on November 29, 2021, 16:16

Title: Battery cut off switch wiring - the great debate!
Post by: moca2cv on November 29, 2021, 16:16
Hi great and knowledgeable team. I will be relocating the battery to the frunk (it's a track car). I will be splashing out on the Mighty UltraMax NP22-12 (used to good effect on most things I've owned!) but what does the collective wisdom suggest is the best way to wire? In the past, I've just chucked it in the negative, but is there a compelling reason to wire it as per the FIA switch instructions in the positive?

Appreciate your thoughts :) I know a lot of people use the little battery clamp screw disconnect doo dah on the negative, so can't imagine there will be any ill effects, unless its used while the engine is running... I do not intend to use it for anything other than preventing the battery from discharging while sat, but at the same time, for a little extra effort, maybe I should do it as per recommended...
Title: Re: Battery cut off switch wiring - the great debate!
Post by: Joesson on November 29, 2021, 17:05


@moca2cv
I didn't know the answer to your question so I checked and found this:


Cartek produce two types of Battery Isolator known as GT and XS. Both systems isolate the battery from all electrical circuits in accordance with FIA requirements) by disconnecting the negative terminal of the battery from the chassis/earth. However, the main difference between these two units is the method used to stop the engine.
https://www.merlinmotorsport.co.uk/pages/cartek-isolator-switches-faq-s-291
Title: Re: Battery cut off switch wiring - the great debate!
Post by: Iain on November 29, 2021, 17:22
Ive done mine on the negative side, had no issues.
Title: Re: Battery cut off switch wiring - the great debate!
Post by: Carolyn on November 29, 2021, 18:02
Isolating the positive prevents arcing to ground in a rescue (or makes it much less likely), thereby reducing fire hazard.
Title: Re: Battery cut off switch wiring - the great debate!
Post by: moca2cv on November 29, 2021, 22:22
Thanks all. And thanks Carolyn - that explains why the guidance says to fit it to the positive. Looks like that will be the most sensible thing to do, don't want to be a fire hazard :)

To conclude:

Either is fine, positive is safest. And safety first etc.
Title: Re: Battery cut off switch wiring - the great debate!
Post by: Joesson on November 29, 2021, 22:58
The isolator switches referred to in the link that I posted are RED! For a reason?


Title: Re: Battery cut off switch wiring - the great debate!
Post by: moca2cv on November 30, 2021, 10:46
Quote from: Joesson on November 29, 2021, 22:58The isolator switches referred to in the link that I posted are RED! For a reason?


I'm sure, but I'm not fitting one of those :)