MR2 Roadster Owners Club

The Workshop => Maintenance, Problems & Troubleshooting => Topic started by: adscan on November 8, 2013, 16:51

Title: Battery issues
Post by: adscan on November 8, 2013, 16:51
I don't use my car that often and it sits on the drive for days at a time. I went to fill up and it started okay but once i filled up and tried to start the car it was dead. All the warning lights came on bit it would not turn over and it just made a clicking sound. Now i don't know the history of the battery but never had any problems so far.
I removed the battery and charged it and now everything seems fine. Having read posts on here about batteries i am concerned that it is dead and will not start again. I have put a meter across it and it is showing 13v off and 14.1v when running.
Does the battery sound good still? Also is 14.1v when running mean any charging issues?
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: mrzwei on November 8, 2013, 17:11
A healthy battery should show between 12.4 to 12.6 Volts. (Don't test it immediately after charging).

With the engine running at around 2000 revs, with all accessories switched off, a healthy alternator should show 13.8 - 14.4 Volts at the battery terminals. (source: Car Mechanics mag. April 12).

The problem is that a duff battery can lose its charge very quickly and it will also charge up very quickly so you can get a false sense of security.
I'd check the voltage first thing in the morning.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: adscan on November 8, 2013, 17:49
Will check it in the morning and see what it reads.

Also, i only do short trips when i do use it so i assume the battery never really gets a chance to charge poperly.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on November 8, 2013, 20:48
If your battery if duff I saw a deal here:   l viewtopic.php?f=57&t=40487&p=547465&hilit=battery#p547465 (http://www.mr2roc.org/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=57&t=40487&p=547465&hilit=battery#p547465) l
Do you have an alarm that may be draining the battery?
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: adscan on November 8, 2013, 23:42
No alarm..
I have seen this offer and will take advantage of it once i have confirmed the battery is fudged.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on November 9, 2013, 08:44
Sounds like the battery is goosed.  Not sure how to do it on the MR2 but if you can disable the car from starting (remove plug leads?) and crank the engine on the starter you will probably find it dies really quickly.  This way tests the battery under full load.  Reconnect everything and recharge the battery and order a new one if needed.
I always think a good battery will get you out of trouble if anything else goes wayward so wouldn't be a waste of money I'm sure.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: adscan on November 9, 2013, 09:23
Just checked it from cold and it's reading 12.2v and 14.3v
Sound okay?
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: locobuilder brian on November 9, 2013, 10:12
Quote from: "purplepowermonster"Sounds like the battery is goosed.  Not sure how to do it on the MR2 but if you can disable the car from starting (remove plug leads?) and crank the engine on the starter you will probably find it dies really quickly.  This way tests the battery under full load.  Reconnect everything and recharge the battery and order a new one if needed.
I always think a good battery will get you out of trouble if anything else goes wayward so wouldn't be a waste of money I'm sure.

Note. Its not a good idea to crank the engine over without trying to start, it could fill the cat with unburnt fuel & kill it !
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: Mikeymead on November 9, 2013, 12:09
Quote from: "adscan"Just checked it from cold and it's reading 12.2v and 14.3v
Sound okay?

The static reading seems low to me but the running reading seems ok. Therefore battery looks like it's on its way out but the alternator seems fine, had a similar problem on my wife's Suzuki Swift a couple of years ago.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: normanh on November 9, 2013, 12:31
If the battery is duff the first cold morning start will show it as it wont have the cold crank current needed to turn the engine over irrespective of what the voltage is, worth checking the earths at this point as well. No solution other than a new battery unless the cgharging system is at fault!


Norman
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: adscan on November 9, 2013, 15:28
Thanks for all the comments..will get a new battery from CTP.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: normanh on November 9, 2013, 16:01
Try Mr T they are about £65 and a stock item as the same as the Yaris from memory.

Norman
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on November 9, 2013, 18:04
Quote from: "locobuilder brian"
Quote from: "purplepowermonster"Sounds like the battery is goosed.  Not sure how to do it on the MR2 but if you can disable the car from starting (remove plug leads?) and crank the engine on the starter you will probably find it dies really quickly.  This way tests the battery under full load.  Reconnect everything and recharge the battery and order a new one if needed.
I always think a good battery will get you out of trouble if anything else goes wayward so wouldn't be a waste of money I'm sure.

Note. Its not a good idea to crank the engine over without trying to start, it could fill the cat with unburnt fuel & kill it !
Blimey,  thanks for putting me right on that, would hate to damage someone's car.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: Wabbitkilla on November 9, 2013, 18:42
You don't say how old the battery is.

It does sound goosed though, the weather getting colder usually highlights the batteries that are getting too old.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: adscan on November 9, 2013, 20:13
Not sure the age of the battery if was fitted when I got the car 15 months ago.

Tried Mr T, they wanted £60 plus VAT. CTP is doing the for £59 posted.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: mrzwei on November 9, 2013, 20:34
Quote from: "adscan"Just checked it from cold and it's reading 12.2v and 14.3v
Sound okay?

12.2 is a bit lower than recommended but it will turn the engine (given enough of Normans amps) and start the car and, as said, the alternator is fine and will recharge the battery.

Normans particular point about the earth is significant, a) because the terminals can be difficult to tighten properly and b) because that would explain why the 'charged' battery suddenly would not work at the garage.

PERSONNALY, I'd monitor it for a few more days. Then, If you are in a position to trickle charge it  that would be ideal, whether it's an old or a new battery because there are loads of historical posts on how quickly the battery loses charge if it's not regularly used. As has been said, this is usually down to the drain caused by the alarm.

If that cold reading was 10 /11 then definitely a new one.

At the end of the day the CTP price is good and you get peace of mind.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: OldMan on November 10, 2013, 03:40
Here in the USA, many auto parts stores will remove the battery, take it into the store, and bench test it under load.  They ususlly perform the servise for free.  Don't auto parts stores in the UK do this??
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: Andys-N20 on November 10, 2013, 07:58
Quote from: "OldMan"Don't auto parts stores in the UK do this??

Yes they do, some will be free and others charge a small fee. Halfords do it.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: normanh on November 10, 2013, 10:24
Some places do in the Uk but almost it will be using the heavy duty ballast resistor type putting the battery under an almost short circuit condition. Its common for that tool to finish the battery off and gassing is seen in one or more of the cells. Its old fashioned it works and it will finish the battery off if slightly dodgey.

Norman
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: OldMan on November 11, 2013, 04:42
Quote from: "normanh"Its old fashioned it works and it will finish the battery off if slightly dodgey.
Euthanizing ailing batteries is good.
Isn't it??   s:? :? s:?
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on December 9, 2013, 21:08
Digging up an old thread here but my problem follows on, leave the car for a week and the battery hasn't enough oomph to turn it over, jump it from a spare battery and away it goes, diagnosis, duff battery.

My dilemma is do I go for a genuine one from CTP at £59 (if Chris still has them) or a Varta from battery megastore at £43.50?  Varta should be a good battery but often the cheapest solution isn't always the best.

 m http://www.batterymegastore.co.uk/product/B32/ (http://www.batterymegastore.co.uk/product/B32/) m

Any help appreciated  :-) :-) :-)
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: Peter Wright on December 9, 2013, 21:19
Quote from: "purplepowermonster"My dilemma is do I go for a genuine one from CTP at £59 (if Chris still has them) or a Varta from battery megastore at £43.50?  Varta should be a good battery but often the cheapest solution isn't always the best.
Im on my third battery now and have found the cheapest place is a Toyota dealer
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: mrzwei on December 9, 2013, 21:20
With a 4 year warranty you can't really go wrong.
The key comparison stats are the AH and the cold cranking.
If you get it fitted, get them to check that the alternator is OK.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on December 12, 2013, 22:06
Eventually made my mind up and ordered at Battery Megastore.  Was £43.50 but found a voucher code (3CD3F3EC5A) so got another 5% off.

Total cost £41.33 delivered, should arrive tomorrow.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on December 13, 2013, 17:05
Quote from: "purplepowermonster"Eventually made my mind up and ordered at Battery Megastore.  Was £43.50 but found a voucher code (3CD3F3EC5A) so got another 5% off.

Total cost £41.33 delivered, should arrive tomorrow.

Battery arrived by 09:30 today and was really well packed.  Now all I need is some time to fit it....
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: parker455 on December 15, 2013, 00:57
Going to order one as I've got the same issue, it's gradually got worse over the past couple of months. Run out of battery at the MOT centre and even when 'charged' the battery doesn't last long. alternator doesn't seem to be the issue so much as I had a long run the other day and the battery 'charged' to a certain degree, but it doesn't seem to be holding charge well.


One of those from battery megastore will fit an import 2001 MR-S won't they?
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on December 15, 2013, 08:07
I guess it would but I measured my existing one to be sure and then checked the website.  I've not fitted mine yet though  s:-D :-D s:-D
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: mr2matt on December 16, 2013, 07:39
Can I join the "cold weather has knackered my battery" club please.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: parker455 on December 16, 2013, 11:16
Request to join the club accepted.

Ordered mine yesterday, 35 quid from battery megastore as they had a 10% code on. Hopefully all is swell with it, should arrive tomorrow.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on December 16, 2013, 21:29
Quote from: "parker455"Request to join the club accepted.

Ordered mine yesterday, 35 quid from battery megastore as they had a 10% code on. Hopefully all is swell with it, should arrive tomorrow.

I was chuffed with my 5% but you've aced me with the 10% code, I wonder is anyone can do better that that.

Thirty five quid for a Varta battery delivered, that's awesome!
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: parker455 on December 16, 2013, 21:58
Quote from: "purplepowermonster"
Quote from: "parker455"Request to join the club accepted.

Ordered mine yesterday, 35 quid from battery megastore as they had a 10% code on. Hopefully all is swell with it, should arrive tomorrow.

I was chuffed with my 5% but you've aced me with the 10% code, I wonder is anyone can do better that that.

Thirty five quid for a Varta battery delivered, that's awesome!

If you sign up on the mobile app they give you the 10% off! Can use the 5% with it too I believe!  s;) ;) s;)

Coming tomorrow, let's hope this goes to plan and it isn't my alternator  s:( :( s:(  nothing but trouble with this motor!
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: mr2matt on December 16, 2013, 23:19
Keep us posted how you get on fitting the varta battery, will get one ordered on payday.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on December 17, 2013, 21:55
Finally got round to fitting the battery tonight, should have guessed the alarm would have gone off when I disconnected the terminals, certainly woke the neighbours up  :-) :-) :-)

Battery fits perfectly so no hesitation in recommending it to anyone else.  Might be just me but the engine seems to crank quicker as well.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: mr2matt on December 17, 2013, 22:17
Thanks for the update and the tip about the alarm. NOTE to self, change battery during day time so as not to  spiss piss spiss  the neighbou'rs off.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: parker455 on December 18, 2013, 01:33
The sods didn't even ring my doorbell today and left a redelivery card for Tomorrow now! Arses. But I'll be fitting mine tomorrow, no alarm so the old dears either side of me shouldn't get to scared I hope  s;) ;) s;)  

Will crank better as more power coming from the battery. Mine, when charged fully, cranks faster but wont hold the charge. Will keep it as a spare though.

Tom
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: purplepowermonster on December 18, 2013, 07:24
Good idea worth the spare, I always have a charged battery in the garage for jump starting, surprising how often it gets used....

Hope you get the battery OK today.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: parker455 on December 18, 2013, 15:22
Cheers mate, nothings arrived still so I've got mine on charge for the afternoon. It's dead though, the charger showed 90% charged when the thing just about started earlier.
Title: Re: Battery issues
Post by: trickyD on February 17, 2014, 09:28
Does anyone have the part number for the correct battery?
or the minimum specs it needs (AH etc)

I get loads of different options...

Thanks